Over the
past week I have received emails from many people about the new Mayor of
Doncaster England.
The subject of the email is: Every Town in England needs a Chief like this. I
did a little research and have outlined some of the differences between Doncaster, England
and Port Coquitlam.
I hope you enjoy.
Population:
Metropolitan Borough of Doncaster: 291,000
Port Coquitlam: 58,000
Equivalent
to the size of the Tri-cities (PoCo 58,000 + PoMo30,000 + Coq 125,000 = 213,000
or 73% the size of Doncaster)
From the
Mayor of Doncaster's Press Release
“cut his salary from £73,000 to
£30,000”
(£30,000 = $53,774.24 CDN
- www.xe.com)
This is not
much different from my current salary. However, I am not sure if we should be
asking our elected politicians to work for less and why we should be asking our
elected politicians to be treated differently from our staff. How many people
reading this BLOG have gone to their employers and suggested they make less during this recession?
Further,
this year we brought together a citizens committee to review the council remuneration.
The committee compared the remuneration of PoCo with other municipalities the
same size. They found that PoCo council is, on average, paid 30% less then
others. However, given the recession the committee and council agreed that now
is not the time for a pay increase.
BTW, the
Mayor of Doncaster, is a retired university teacher, so I am sure he is
receiving a government pension and collecting his mayoral salary – double
dipping!
“town councillors cut from 63 to
just 21”
This should
have been done LONG ago. If you think
PoCo Council meetings are long with each Councillor and Mayor saying his / her
piece on an issue, imagine an additional 57 speeches! The savings on hydro alone with the
"councillor reduction" must be huge! Not to mention the volume of
paper required to produce 63 agendas and other printed material!
In Port Coquitlam we only
have 6 councillors. Under Legislation we are permitted to have 8 but at this
time we do not need to spend the extra money for more councillors. (We also put this issue to the voters in
2005).
BTW, the city councillors in the two cities receive about the same base salary,
but instead of 6 people sharing the work load there are 21. Other than agreeing with each other, I have
no idea what those additional councillors would be doing. (It is interesting to note that Vancouver – population approx. 570,000
- has only 10 councillors.) I guess being blessed with a hard working and
efficient City Council has me thinking this way.
Further, in
Doncaster each councillor receives the
following additional stipend:
For chairing
a committee: $11,256 per year
For
vice-chairing a committee: $4,558 per year
Port
Coquitlam City Council members each chair and co-chair at least one committee,
as well as serve on other task forces and committees in our community. There is
no additional remuneration for this responsibility and additional workload.
Total equivalent cost for a Port
Coquitlam City Councillor (if we used the Doncaster
pay scale) $56,557. I think we are doing pretty well.
“mayor’s chauffeur-driven car has
also been axed”
Wow, the
Mayor had his own chauffeur-driven car?! We don’t have a chauffeur to cut.
Besides,
since I ride my bike to most meetings and events in the City, having a tandem
bike would be ridiculous (except for May Day Parades of course).
I think
before we start making judgment on the local politicians we should make sure we
are comparing ‘apples to apples’. Given that the Mayor of Doncaster had a
chauffer-driven car, I wonder what other perks he is receiving? It’s more
likely that he’s just cutting a lot of the fat that doesn’t exist in Port Coquitlam in the
first place.
Here are
some other initiatives the Doncaster Mayor has undertaken:
- Stopped
future funding for gay pride event (£3,000)
- Stopped
council newspaper, Doncaster News
- Where
possible, stopped funding for translation services and instead encourage
people to learn English
- No
mention of withdrawing from local gov’t association? That’s an option for us?
- What
about twinning / sister cities? Not something we do, but something we’re
considering.
Let me ask
you - which events or items in Port
Coquitlam would you cut?
This has
been an interesting comparison
I look
forward to reading your comments.